Amelia Butterworth

The proud, observant narrator and amateur detective whose domestic knowledge repeatedly challenges the police theory.

Ebenezer Gryce

The veteran detective from earlier Green novels, alternately amused, frustrated, and impressed by Amelia's investigation.

Louise Van Burnam

Howard's estranged wife and the actual murder victim, mistakenly killed in the dark.

Howard Van Burnam

Louise's husband, whose evasions and apparent recognition of the body make him the first major suspect.

Franklin Van Burnam

Howard's brother, later arrested when a compromising letter and evidence about the keys point toward him.

Silas Van Burnam

The family patriarch, deeply distressed by the case and protective of both sons.

Caroline and Isabella Van Burnam

The brothers' sisters, who befriend Amelia and help her reenter the crime scene.

Ruth Oliver

John Randolph's abandoned wife, the intended victim who escapes after disguising the dead Louise in her clothes.

John Randolph / Randolph Stone

Ruth's bigamous husband and Louise's killer, determined to remove Ruth so he can marry Miss Althorpe.

Miss Althorpe

The wealthy young woman engaged to Stone, who shelters Ruth without initially knowing the full connection.

Mrs. Boppert

A cleaning woman whose testimony and actions around the empty house become important to Amelia's reconstruction.